SCMEA Concert Festival
For Comments Only*
Repertoire (Title, Composer, Arranger)
IV V VI
IV V VI
*Comments Only. Directors who wish to receive comments only must write the words “Comments Only” in the
Rating box at the top of the evaluation form on the other side of this page. Adjudicators will give each group scores
and a final rating unless the director wishes to receive comments only.
Make sure to include original scores for each judge with the measures numbered. Photocopies will only be accepted
if accompanied by a letter or fax from the publisher granting permission to use photocopies.
Reserved for uncommonly exceptional groups that stand out as having performances that
are nearly flawless.
Truly fine work; worthy of compliment and praise. Students are performing well.
Performance demonstrates some good technical and musical achievements; however,
improvement is needed to be considered excellent.
A moderate number of significant problems mar the desired positive effect of the
Many, severe problems mar the desired positive effect of the performance.
I. Superior (103-125)
I. Superior (83-100)
II. Excellent (83-102)
II. Excellent (67-82)
III. Good (63-82)
III. Good (51-66)
IV. Fair (43-62)
IV. Fair (35-50)
V. Poor (25-42)
V. Poor (20-34)
42-50 Superior (I)
34-41 Excellent (II)
26-33 Good (III)
18-25 Fair (IV)
10-17 Poor (V)